Should Women Be Allowed During Combat Roles During The...

In a recent poll posted on Debate.org titled Should Women Be Allowed To Serve In Combat Roles In The Armed Forces? 71% of voters said yes while the other 29% said no. For this dispute majority rules is irrelevant, in fact minority rules and the 29% can tally up another vote and argue that no, women should not be allowed to serve in combat roles in the armed forces. Although there have been cases where women find themselves in a surprise firefight and are expected to pick up the weapon to their left or right and rightfully defend, that doesn’t mean they are prepared to tackle the rest of the responsibilities that come alongside combat roles. A common opposition for those in favor of equal rights all around in the armed forces is that women are equally as capable as men. Mental strength might be worth discussing, but physical strength between men and women simply does not compare. A study in the Journal of Applied Physiology concluded that men had an average of 26 lbs. more skeletal muscle mass than women. Women also tested to have approximately 40% less upper-body strength and 33% less lower-body strength. Those numbers speak volumes, no pun intended. When a man becomes a casualty on the battlefield not just any woman can muster the strength to drag/carry that 180 lb. man back to safety on her own. Although there are a few exceptions, the likeliness of the average woman being able to perform that task is slim to none. Along the same lines, the average infantry soldierShow MoreRelatedWomen in the Military Essay1469 Words   |  6 Pages Women have fought alongside men in the United States Military in every major battle since the American Revolution. The roles of women in the military have evolved over time to allow the incorporation of women in expanding military career fields. Women have proven themselves to be an asset to the military despite some of society believing women would weaken America’s military effectiveness. Today more than 200,000 women are active-duty military, this is about 14.5% of all military. Currently, womenRead MoreGender Roles Of Women s Roles971 Words   |  4 PagesTransforming Gender. Women’s Roles in Society. Why are men always in power? Or is that we just assume that they have power? In recent years, the roles of women have changed greatly in American society.   For example, women have earned more power in education, the workplace and especially the military (Cordes). Yet, when it comes to women being fully integrated in the military, many males still question female co mpetency. This situation needs to be addressed because women are physically, emotionallyRead MoreWomen s Roles During The American Armed Forces1409 Words   |  6 PagesCombat roles are grueling and nerve breaking, with a lot of commitment and endurance required. Masculinity is the most suited trait for anyone to fit adequately and perform effectively. Mostly, men fit well in these roles due to their masculinity. However, women too, can perform as equally as effective as men. The effectiveness and suitability of inclusion of women in major combat roles in the American Armed forces has faced heated debates, between people who believe that the combat roles are mostRead MoreThe Pros And Cons Of Women Serving During Combat Roles893 Words   |  4 Pages The Pros and Cons of Women Serving in Combat Roles A number of arguments have been raised in defense of a military policy that bans women from serving in combat roles. Pros argues that women should be allowed to serve in combat roles in the Armed Forces. Cons argues that women should not serve in combat roles because they would not be as effective in combat as their counterparts. 1. Cons of women serving in combat roles in the armed forces. A. Physical Ability – Some jobs in theRead MoreWomen s Armed Services Integration Act1159 Words   |  5 PagesWomen now make up 14 percent of the active-duty military in the United States, which is up from 1.6 percent, 25 years prior. (Christian Science Monitor, 1). In 1948, President Truman signed the Women s Armed Services Integration Act which created the role of women in the military. This law meant that each branch of the service was allowed to have one female Colonel (Byfield, 12). As of 2015, there are many women who serve as Generals and Admirals. All of these roles are non-combative. Even thoughRead MoreWomens Fight For Women1361 Words   |  6 PagesWomen in Combat For a long time now women have been an important part of the U.S. military, having performed admirably in Operations Iraqi Freedom and Enduring Freedom. The debate on whether women should play a role in combat has been a long standing debate that has not yet reached a consensus. According to Daniel Davis in his article â€Å"The Truth About Women in Ground Combat Roles† President Obama commended the December 3 decision by Secretary of Defense Ash Carter to open all combat jobs to womenRead MoreRoles Of Women During History903 Words   |  4 Pages Women throughout history have made great strides in gender equality. Unfortunately, there is still a long way to go. Career choices should be just that; a choice, not exclusion solely based upon gender. Joining the armed services for most is about service to your country, honor, and pride: For women this also includes limitations. Is it fair to limit what is accepted from women in terms of what roles they are allowed to serve in? Excluding women from serving in certain combat units sends aRead MorePolicy Introduction And Identification Of The Military Services And United State s Special Operations Command1453 Words   |  6 Pagesof 2013, the Department of Defense set aside the â€Å"1994 Direct Ground Combat Definition and Assignment Rule† (Carter, 2015). This takes all restrictions off women allowing all who meet the qualifications to hold a combat role in the military. The Armed Forces have opened over 110,000 positions to women and have set their standards. Anyone, who can meet operationally relevant and gender neutral standards, regardless of gender, should have the opportunity to serve in any position (Carter, 2015). TheRead MoreEssay Military Women Should NOT Be Allowed in Combat Positions1652 Words   |  7 PagesThe prospect of women in ground combat or on the front-line in the military has proven to be a controversial issue throughout decades of war. This controversy stems from criticisms such as women’s physicality versus men’s, the association of sexual-related situations within the military, and a history of failed gen der-integration training. The bottom line, however, is that women should not be allowed in front-line or ground combat unless they are willing and capable of meeting the same standardsRead MoreWomen s Rights Of Women1086 Words   |  5 Pagesyears. From suffrage being granted to Women, to people of different races being able to attend the same unsegregated schools. Yet, equal treatment and opportunities for all is still not assured in our society. A blatant example of this is the controversy around allowing women to serve in combat roles. Many detractors try to make the case of females being mentally and physically unsuited for the harsh trials of combat, therefore wanting to bar them from those roles. These critics fail to recognize the